Our website would like to use cookies to store information on your computer. You may delete and block all cookies from this site, but parts of the site will not work as a result. Find out more about how we use cookies.
Renew-Reuse-Recycle
23rd May 2013 Login  
Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine
by Simon Ridout at 2006-12-14 14:48:08 (Ask an Expert)
I am in the process of applying for planning permission for a Proven Energy 6KW wind turbine on a 15 mast. My application is 7/2006/4107 with the Lake District National Park Authority. My searches show that a 6KW turbine was approved in the park in September, albeit on a 9m tower, so I am not applying for a ground breaking precedent.
Has anyone got any useful information and/or experience about the process of installing a wind turbine and the actual output. I am siting the trubine in open ground, at the top of a gentle slope to the SW, about 250m from the house. Estimated windspeed is 6m/s. I will be applying for a grant once planning permission is granted, do you know how long this process takes? Realistically, I will not be able to start work on the foundations until the ground had dried out, driving a 4wd tractor or JCB across the fields will make a site fit for mud wrestling!
--
Simonridout

Mail this to a friend
Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2006-12-14 14:48:08
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Stuart - 2006-12-15 09:50:18
Hi

Sounds like you have got a good location there. I assume the 6ms is at 10m. So your wind speed at turbine height would be 6.3 say. This is a very good wind speed. Placing a turbine on a slope is good but you may want to investigate this further as it is often best not to place it at the crest of the hill, because the wind speed drops as the wind escapes the compression of the slope. Slightly down the slop may be better.

As to the output. No Proven owner I know has ever got anywhere near the output they predict, But then the perfect roughness conditions the outputs are predicated upon are very rare (the Isle of Lewis et al) but you will get a very good output at your site. If your site is open ground, without trees and hedgerows.

I am on course for an output of 3000 kWh a year or more. My wind speed is 5.7/5.9ms at 10m and the area is quite rough with some trees and houses around my turbine 6 kWh on a 15m mast.

Some else I know in Kent with the same turbine with 5.9/6ms at 10s has a record of 11,000 kWh in three plus years. He is set in open farm land but with a bank of large trees in the prevailing wind direction.

The Hockerton Housing Project have a 6kw Proven on a 25m guyed tower. The reckon they get about 5000 kWh a year. They have a wind speed of 4.5ms. So the tower height here is the important factor.

I would not be surprised if you could achieve 8000+ units a year.

In Scotland on some of the islands I am told through my ROC seller that some Provens have 30,000 kWh.

Hope this helps. Have look round the site as there is loads of other bits that can help you,

Stuart

--
Stuart

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Ted Marynicz - 2006-12-18 12:31:44
Hello Simon,

what sort of information on the installation are you looking for?

There is a set of photos showing the process here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/caerdelyn/sets/1297165/

ted

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-01-03 10:51:14
Stuart - Many thanks for the information. My choice of position is rather limited by the land that I own, this stops me going down the slope from the crest of the rise.

Ted - my exam question is 'is there anything that you now know about the process of purchasing, installing and commissioning a turbine that you wish you knew at the outset'!

Best wishes and Happy New Year
--
Simonridout

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-01-22 14:55:14
Planning permission has been granted LAke District National Park Authority 7/2006/4107 refers.

Hopefully this successful application will help others in National Parks or other sensitive areas.

The next step is to make a successful grant application. Any tips or advice will be greatly appreciated, including what to expect from the process, how long it takes, does it involve an inspection of my house?
--
Simonridout

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-02-01 08:00:18
More progress, grant application has been made and approved. Next step is to order the turbine and prepare the site.
--
Simonridout
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Stuart - 2007-02-01 16:57:12
Well done.

How easy was the grant process. How did they verify that you have an insulated house etc. I believe that this is a new requirment?
--
Stuart

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-02-02 10:11:29
It was very easy, I completed the on line application and it was approved instantly. In applying, you agree to the conditions of the grant, which includes stating that you have the required energy saving measures - insulation, low energy bulbs etc and that you agree to an inspection from the Energy Saving Trust (with reasonable notice).

Money for the grant is allocated monthly, January's had run out, so I stayed up and applied a few minutes after midnight on the 1st of Feb, to be certain, however information from the telephone helpline suggests that the money lasts till mid month before running out.

The grant is basically a 'cashback' after completion of the installation, together with a certificate of completion from the installer and receipted invoices for the work.
--
Simonridout

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-04-21 18:50:25
Foundations poured today, the turbine goes up on 17 May!
--
Simonridout
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Stuart - 2007-04-21 19:21:45
Great News!

Let us know how you get on and do please post some pictures.

Good luck

--
Stuart

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-05-11 09:14:24
Delivery/ installation has been postponed because Proven cannot supply the 15 m tower at present. Has anyone else had this problem? It is 13 weeks since I placed my firm order.
--
Simonridout
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Stuart - 2007-05-11 14:14:52
I dont think Proven make the towers? So you may be able to source it elsewhere?
--
Stuart
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-05-11 16:09:25
Yes, it is probably a contracted out supplier, however I do not expect it would be easy to find the tower specification and seek an alternative supplier who had one in stock, to the same specs. I am not anticipating a delay of more than 1-2 weeks.
--
Simonridout
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-05-24 19:03:24
Latest difficulty is that United Utilities say that the transformer supplying the house is only capable of handling 4KW and needs adjusting to handle 6KW. This will cost me £1000-1500. I do not understand the electrics, if I can take 80amps / 20KW from the supply, why can I not put 24 amps / 6KW back in?
Can any one please explain! Has anyone else had this problem?

Simon Ridout
--
Simonridout

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine muymalestado - 2007-05-25 09:06:44
Are energy companies coming over all avaricious and dreaming up new ways to charge whomever they can find to charge for whatever they can think to charge for? Shareholders delight!
--
muymalestado
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Ted Marynicz - 2007-05-28 17:15:26
Simon,

is this transformer dedicated just to your house or shared with neighbours?

It could be a 5kVA unit which means it is designed to only handle a sustained throughput of 21 Amps (5000/230). The fact that you have an 80 Amp fuse from the grid doesn't mean that you can actually use that much for other than short periods. (Fuses are there to protect the cables from melting.)

If the DNO thinks you will be exporting 26 Amps (6000/230) for extended periods then they will want to upgrade the transformer.

Can you find out what size the transformer is?

ted

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-05-31 08:34:17
The turbine was installed yesterday, all went well - it took a team of 3 plus myself driving the tractor just less than 8 hours.

The transformer only supplies my house, however it was undersized for when the farm was a working farm with high power demand for milking coolers etc. Therefore it was 'tapped up' to give 253 volts to maximise power output. This makes it sensitive to high input voltages, causing the windyboy inverter to trip out, unless there is a high load in the house.

I will report developments. The next step is to get the export meter fitted and sign up to sell the excess and ROCs.
--
Simonridout

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Stuart - 2007-05-31 14:28:29
Simon,

Do you have two 3000 inverters or one 6000?

It would be good to see some pics of your turbine.
--
Stuart

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-05-31 15:09:25
One 6000 inverter. I have some photos, however I have not yet mastered the trick of getting them from photoshop elements to this site!
--
Simonridout
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Website Administrator - 2007-05-31 15:41:15
Hi,

JPEG and GIF image files are supported, photos will usually be JPEG. Don't forget to shrink the image to web resolution before uploading - I tend to resize mine to 320x240 or 640x480 pixels, or thereabouts.

Using the 'Attach' button on the preview page for a posting, you can browse to find a file on your local machine and then upload it.

Choose the appropriate file format from the drop down menu on the attachment upload form, and enter a brief description of the file, then hit 'Upload'.

Once it's uploaded, use the 'Return to display of content' link to get back to the preview page, where you can hit the 'Attach' button again if you want to upload a second file. Repeat as necessary.

Cheers
--
Website Administrator

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Windy Miller - 2007-06-25 09:20:18
Simon,

This should have been picked up by your installer when they made the enquiry to the utility company prior to quoting. They should have then included the cost of the transformer upgrade in the quote, so that it would only attract 5% VAT, and be included in the grant fundable works (even though with a Proven 6 you would have 'maxed out' on the grant"

When an installer carries out a site visit, prior to quoting, grid connection capacity is one of the things they should be looking at to make sure that your proposed installation is viable.
--
Windy Miller

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-07-20 06:34:08
Some good news at last. The Grant cheque arrived yesterday. The payment has taken about 5 weeks to process, which is not too bad and much better than some of the delays that I have heard about.
--
Simonridout
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-08-22 10:07:46
More problems. After the core was replaced (this has been described in Stuart's 'my turbine is broken thread') the turbine worked well for about 2 weeks. Then there was a problem on start up with the turbine providing an over volt supply into the inverter. Turbine services fitted 3 x 2 KW DC heaters to work as a heat/power sink if the turbine overvolted, so as to protect the inverter. However this was not enough to survive a summer gale. If the inverter shut down, either for over volting the mains or because of a frequency mismatch, the heat sink would kick in while the inverter tried to start up again. However on one occasion it was not enough, with the inverter making a poping noise, followed by displaying an earth fault.

Investigation showed a blown capacitor, which is being replaced. A better over volt protection system is being fitted next week. In the mean time the turbine is free wheeling and in my first 3 months of operation I will have had 2 months of down time and only 200 KWH generated, all rather disappointing. While my high mains voltage, due to my transformer having been 'tapped up' makes my inverter shut down, I refuse to accept this as a cause of the problem, it would be no different from if there was a power cut during a period of high winds.

Has anyone else had problems of the turbine over volting when the inverter has disconnected and is trying to start up?
--
Simonridout

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Windy Miller - 2007-08-22 10:45:29
Simon

High DC input voltage is not related to your high AC grid voltage. The two are completely seperate, so you are right to refuse to accept the connection between the 2. High DC voltage when the turbine is unloaded is a result of poor speed control. Other words on this at...

www.renew-reuse-recycle.com/showarticle.pl?id=944

Over-voltage on the grid is a seperate problem, yet one which also needs resolving, as it results in unnecessary downtime. Your utility company perhaps need re tap your supply transformer again so that your supply voltage is within 10% of 230V. If you are regularly tripping on G83/1 overvoltage, it sounds like your supply voltage is too high, even when not generating. Bear in mind that a few years ago, the UK nominal voltage reduced from 240 to 230 volts. If your supply was tapped to 240V + 10% (264 volts), its now way over the current maximum of 230 + 10% = 253 volts.

--
Windy Miller

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-08-22 11:55:21
Windy
Thank you. At present the mains is at 253volts. UU are due to tap down the transformer to ?230 volts (I am the only house supplied and it was probably tapped up when it was a working farm with milking machines, coolers etc) However they move at a speed which makes a snail seem fast.
--
Simonridout
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-10-03 09:23:48
My latest problem is twisted springs. This has happened twice, the first time, shown in the pictures, two sets of springs became twisted. The tower was lowered, all three sets replaced, because the twisting had stretched some so the reistance was different on each blade. The problem has recurred, this time affecting all three blades.
Does anyone know why this is happening?

http://picasaweb.google.com/thornflatt/turbine
--
Simonridout

Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Stuart - 2007-10-04 10:04:42
I havent seen this before, are the springs fitted correctly?
--
Stuart
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Simon Ridout - 2007-10-08 08:52:04
Problem solved! Careful examination of the pictures will show that the wedges have been fitted incorrectly. This occurred 2+ months ago when the core was replaced. It was the cause of the overvolting, control box burnout, inverter capacitor blowing etc.
On the one hand I am disappointed that it took so long to discover and rectify, including not being noticed when the tower was lowered to replace the springs for the first time. However, on the other hand, I am very pleased that a definate fault has been found and rectified.
Now all that I need is some wind, once I have seen the turbine working well in a gale, I am sure that I will re-establish my confidence in the installation.
The installer's over voltage protection device has now been taken out. Turbine Services tell me that they are liaising Povern about developing an over voltage protector which may then be fitted as standard.
The lesson is: WHEN THE BLADES ARE FITTED CHECK AND DOUBLE CHECK THAT THE WEDGES ARE CORRECT!
Simon
--
Simonridout
Re: Proven Energy 6KW Wind Turbine Alexei Vodopianov - 2009-06-25 14:49:00
I am glad you ve got your turbine to work well.
I would like to install the Proven 6 at home in Cyprus.This is really a lot of things to learn from your experience.Also if some one knows
how to earth the tower.I ve heard the Proven towers have a earth point.I also know lot of towers connected to the earth rod with 16 sq.mm cable.Is ity thesame with 15 m Proven tower?Any ideas will be much appriciated.
--
AVV
If you'd like to post comments on this site, just register here

Powered by Novacaster